Bitcoin developers are debating a proposal that could fundamentally change what the alpha crypto and network is used for, dividing the community between those who see it as necessary progress and others who fear it threatens Bitcoin's core purpose.
At issue is a technical change called "removing OP_RETURN limits."
If approved, it would allow people to store much larger amounts of non-financial data directly on the Bitcoin blockchain, for use in things like text and images.
The issue
Currently, Bitcoin limits this type of data storage to small 83-byte chunks (80 bytes of data plus 3 bytes for opcodes), roughly enough for a short message.
An opcode (operation code) is a basic instruction in Bitcoin's scripting language that tells it to do something.
By removing OP_RETURN limits, much larger data sets could be embedded in transactions, though still constrained by Bitcoin's transaction size limits of 100 kilobytes.
However, data-heavy transactions could compete with financial ones, which may drive up fees.
Changing the limits
Peter Todd, who last year denied rumors that he was Bitcoin creator Satoshi Nakamoto, proposed the change. The Bitcoin developer argues that people are already bypassing these limits through technical workarounds.
Bitcoin Core, the main open-source software that runs the Bitcoin network, shouldn't have to maintain "arbitrary limits" which are ostensibly "ineffective, and even harmful," Todd wrote in comments.
Responding to the idea, longtime Bitcoin Core contributor Jason Hughes opposed the change.
"Bitcoin Core developers are about to merge a change that turns Bitcoin into a worthless altcoin, and no one seems to care to do anything about it," Hughes tweeted.
Bitcoin Core developers are about to merge a change that turns Bitcoin into a worthless altcoin, and no one seems to care to do anything about it.
I've voiced objections, lost sleep over this, and despite clear community rejection of the PR it's moving.https://t.co/dMcQ4g8RjV
"This is far more than a small technical change.” Hughes elaborated in the Bitcoin development mailing list. “This is a fundamental change to the nature of what the Bitcoin network itself is in its entirety."
While supportive of the change, Bitcoin Core developer Pieter Wuille acknowledged criticisms of the proposal.
"I'm not happy with seeing the demand for those transactions," he said. "But I also recognize the reality that that demand exists, and the alternative of pushing that demand to bypass the public network is far more damaging."
By late Tuesday evening, Todd and other Bitcoin Core developers had allegedly made a new pull request, doing so because they "couldn't take the community heat," Hughes claimed.
Still, supporters of the proposal see it as a step to turning Bitcoin into a programmable platform that supports broader use cases, beyond simple payments or value transfer.
Daily Debrief Newsletter
Start every day with the top news stories right now, plus original features, a podcast, videos and more.
As catastrophic floods ravage central Texas and North Carolina, emergency responders are using professional and military-grade drones with infrared and real-time video to map flood zones, locate stranded victims, and direct rescue teams.
In Texas, MQ-9 Reapers flying 18,000 feet above the impacted area assisted first responders in locating missing victims of the flooding, including those from Camp Mystic, a summer camp where 27 children and counselors lost their lives.
But while drones assist in...
Minna Bank, Japan’s first digital-only bank and a subsidiary of Fukuoka Financial Group, announced Thursday it is exploring the use of stablecoins and digital wallets to support everyday financial services and payments in the country.
The initiative is part of a joint study in collaboration with Fireblocks, Solana Japan, and Japanese tech firm TIS, aiming to assess the practical applications of stablecoins and decentralized wallets in real-world banking.
The study will examine use cases includin...
If you follow the latest in Bitcoin happenings, then you may have seen the name “Alkanes” pop up on your timeline via Ordinals and Runes enjoyers. But what is it?
Alkanes is a new metaprotocol built on Bitcoin that introduces trustless smart contract functionality to the base layer, without relying on bridges or external execution layers. It allows developers to build apps and launch tokens natively on Bitcoin, expanding the functionality of the original blockchain.
Developed by Oyl Corp, the pr...