Twitter opened a new can of worms in the censorship debate on Tuesday by“fact-checking” posts by President Donald Trump, suggesting he was wrong about voter fraud.
Meanwhile, YouTube has beendeleting comments with phrases that insult China’s Communist Party, and its sister company, Google,deleted millions of TikTok reviews. after the app's ratings fell to an all-time low.
Millions of TikTok reviews have been deleted. Image: Shutterstock.
The tech titans have sought to explain away these latest swipes at the citadel of free speech. It’sbecause of automated filters, introduced due to workforce changes during the pandemic, argued YouTube; it’sto curb spam abuse, Google said, in reference to Tik Tok. Meanwhile, Twitter politely explained that the President simply violated its new “civic integrity policy,” which bars users from posting misleading information that could dissuade people from voting.
But many are having none of it. Today, Mati Greenspan, founder of Quantum Economics, asked his Twitter followers: “What have you done to #ungoogle yourself lately?”
Up to now,Twitter has proven a willing participant in Trump’s misinformation campaign. But good luck to him in getting its latest decision reversed. As millions of banned accounts have discovered,federal law protects the rights of internet platforms to moderate the third-party speech they publish. And Twitter has stuck to its guns.
YouTube’s censorship crisis
Not so YouTube. It has since promised to fix the “enforcement systems’ error” that has led thousands of comments criticising China’s ruling Communist Party to be removed—a mistake that’s apparently gone unnoticed since October 2019, when theissue was raised on YouTube’s official help pages.
YouTube has been accused of censoring crypto content. Image: Shutterstock.
But it has plenty of other critics, including Elon Musk. In April, heslammed YouTube for removing a video of two doctors who were urging an end to lockdowns.
And there are signs a YouTube backlash may have begun. Podcaster and sports commentatorJoe Rogan announced hismove to Spotify last week, while lambasting Google’s heavy-handed censorship of content providers.
Popular crypto vlogger Ivan on Tech announced a move over on to his own platform earlier this month, after YouTube repeatedly censored his content. The cryptocurrency industry, often portrayed as a scammer haven, is an obvious target for social media censorship across all social media platforms.
Social media platform’s policies towards cryptocurrency companies have often been uneven. For instance, on Google, genuine companies have complained of being banned from placing ads on its site, while the platform seeminglyallows phishing sites who impersonate them.
On Facebook, some users have complained thatusing the single word coronavirus means a post is auto-censored. The platform hopes its newOversight Board will resolve censorship dilemmas, but critics warn that “platform governance means platform interference,” and even the most qualified, objective censors are still censors, forced to make subjective distinctions between ‘good’ and ‘bad’ speech.
Political advertising is running riot in our democracies. In Brexit-beleaguered Britain, campaigns are running unverified claims on buses, while their sources of funding remain unclear. In the US, things are no better. During Mark Zuckerberg’s recent testimony to Congress, Democrat Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez challenged the Facebook founder, pointing out that under the social network’s fact-checking policy, she could run ads falsely claiming that Republicans supported her policies with impunit...
In fact, earlier this month, Tyler Winklevoss—cofounder of the Gemini crypto exchange and a venture capitalist known for his tussles with Facebook in the past—called forcrypto entrepreneurs to start building the uncensorable social networks of the future. “A central party should not play referee,” Winklevoss told Decrypt, at the time.
Tyler Winklevoss, pictured with his brother Cameron, has called on crypto firms to build more decentralized platforms to combat censorship.
Cryptocurrency offers interesting possibilities for self-censorship. Reddit, for instance, is running anexperiment using crypto as a measure of reputation, earned by submitting quality posts and comments.
The social media platform said itsvision was for a new frontier: a free and fair Internet. It claims the Internet has been ruined by advertising, censorship and “walled gardens,” and cryptocurrency might offer a way out.
The social media giants know that the battle isn’t really about spam or fraud. It’s about who gets to define truth. And there’s some consolation that Trump is subject to that too.
Daily Debrief Newsletter
Start every day with the top news stories right now, plus original features, a podcast, videos and more.
Users of popular payments apps PayPal and Venmo will soon be able to buy, sell, hold, and transfer Solana and Chainlink from directly inside their accounts alongside leading cryptocurrencies Bitcoin and Ethereum.
PayPal said that adding the new coins, which are both among the top 15 most valuable cryptocurrencies by market cap respectively according to data from CoinGecko, reflects the company’s "dedication to the evolving digital currency landscape.”
“Since we initially made cryptocurrencies a...
GameStop CEO Ryan Cohen has purchased $10.7 million in GME stock, eight days after the video game retailer announced its plans to add Bitcoin to its treasury reserve.
Cohen bought 500,000 Class A shares of GME at $21.55 per share, according to a financial disclosure filed on April 3 with the Securities Exchange Commission. The executive now holds 8.4% of stock issued by GameStop, or 37,347,842 shares.
GameStop's stock closed at $23.49 on Friday, up more than 11%. Shares are down about 50% sinc...
With millions lost to crypto fraud in Illinois, a new bill aims to tighten regulations in the digital asset space.
On Thursday, the Illinois Senate Executive Committee passed Senate Bill 1797, the Digital Assets and Consumer Protection Act, which seeks to regulate digital asset businesses within the state.
The bill, first introduced in February by State Sen. Mark Walker (D-Arlington Heights), aims to address the mounting problem of crypto fraud, which led to over $163 million in losses in Illino...