It’s been a good summer for digital assets in Europe—especially when compared to the cold reception they have endured in the United States.
In August, the continent welcomed the launch of its first exchange traded fund (ETF) in Bitcoin spot markets with the listing of the Jacobi FT Wilshire Bitcoin ETF in Amsterdam. On the regulatory front, the European Union's Markets in Crypto Assets (MiCA), a comprehensive framework designed around digital assets, created legal clarity for digital asset companies in the bloc.
In the U.S., digital assets had a rougher season. Despite some high-profile spot ETF applications by Wall Street heavyweights like BlackRock and Fidelity, the Securities and Exchange Commission has slow-rolled any approvals, creating a drag on Bitcoin markets. At the same time, it has continued its crackdown on crypto exchanges, while Congress struggles to get its own regulatory bill passed.
‘Disappointing’ ETF Decisions By SEC Blamed for Bitcoin Selloff
Institutions are “disappointed” by the SEC’s lack of decision-making regarding an ETF, according to the most recent report from CoinShares, prompting a widespread sell-off by large entities totalling an impressive $55 million worth of digital asset outflows in the past seven days. As James Butterfill, head of research for CoinShares wrote, “Disappointment from SEC ETF decisions has impacted sentiment,” with Bitcoin’s outflows reversing last week’s purchases worth $27 million. Butterfill explai...
For envious industry players in the U.S., the trans-Atlantic contrast is proof that Europe is surging further ahead. Lars Christensen, chairman of the board for Concordium, said Europe “hasn’t been good at eating America's lunch for years”—but that this summer’s moves show how clear regulations are a major competitive advantage.
“I would say Europe is probably a bit ahead of the game,” Christensen told Decrypt in an interview. “In this sense, the U.S. still has work to do.”
Europe’s ascent up the list of digital asset-friendly jurisdictions has been clear. In 2022, Europe overtook the U.S. as a springboard for digital asset startups with 3,977 launched versus 3,357 in the U.S., according to data from DealBook. Even in funding—where the U.S. remains dominant—European startups saw a 14% increase in venture capital investment compared to a 4% drop in the U.S. last year.
MiCA Spurs Surge in VC Funding for EU-Based Crypto Startups
An influx of VC funding has flowed into the European crypto market over the past couple months—something executives have said is because of the landmark crypto regulation in the European Union. Markets in Crypto Assets (MiCA), is a regulatory framework that was approved earlier this year and will likely become law in July this year. The legislation aims to regulate crypto assets and those engaged in transacting them, whether they are people or entities. That makes it the first major step towards...
As the traditional haven for legacy tech and finance industries, having the U.S trailing behind Europe is something of a role reversal. For decades, U.S. regulations have been considered the less onerous of the two, whereas Europe was regarded as more bureaucratic, with more stringent rules to abide by.
This inversion of roles is made clear with Europe beating the U.S. to the front of the line in the race for a Bitcoin spot ETF. Unlike in the U.S., where the pursuit of a Bitcoin spot ETF is a decade-long ordeal of constant rejections, exchange traded products related to Bitcoin have been active in Europe since at least 2015 with the introduction of Sweden-based XBT Bitcoin Tracker One.
Despite the SEC’s concerns about a spot ETF being prone to market manipulation, Christensen said that the debate has not been as contentious in Europe.
Judges Scrutinize SEC Over Denial of Grayscale Bitcoin ETF
Judges overseeing Grayscale’s lawsuit against the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) questioned the financial watchdog Tuesday, digging into the agency’s basis for denying Grayscale’s application to establish a Bitcoin ETF. The questions came during oral arguments in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit, overseen by Judges Sri Srinivasan, Neomi Rao, and Harry Edwards. Grayscale initiated legal action against the SEC in June of last year, after an application to convert its Graysc...
“I don't remember that controversy at the time, and in Europe, it didn't seem to be something that interested an awful lot of regulators very much,” said Christensen.
The nature of the U.S. regulatory system also presents unique challenges that are more salient than across the pond.
Lowell Ness, a lead partner on Fintech at the law firm Perkins Coie, said that U.S. securities laws are designed to be “intentionally vague” in a manner that differs from what he described as a more “cut and dry” approach in Europe. This gives U.S. regulators more flexibility in setting rules but also lends itself to turf wars between agencies.
SEC’s Hester Peirce Says Agency's Current Approach Is 'Not a Good Way of Regulating'
There has been little love lost between the Securities and Exchange Commission and the crypto industry. For years, the federal agency has taken a hard line against the novel sector, pursuing sporadic enforcement actions against individual crypto companies but offering little in terms of a coherent regulatory policy that crypto projects could look to for guidance. Industry leaders have long accused the SEC of taking a uniquely unfair and unreasonable approach to crypto regulation; now, one of th...
The lack of formal rules from regulators—or even definitions for digital assets in the U.S.—has only exacerbated the problem. Companies have responded to this by lobbying Congress to clean up the mess. In another case, Coinbase, the biggest exchange in America, petitioned the SEC directly for rules—but has been met with silence and a lawsuit accusing it of violating securities laws.
This lack of clarity has driven some U.S. companies to consider moving operations overseas. One example of this was the U.S. arm of digital asset exchange Bittrex. In April, the exchange said it would be shutting down because operating in the U.S. was no longer “economically viable” because of its haphazard regulatory system.
Oliver Linch, Bittrex’s CEO, said that the U.S. fixation on “navel-gazing debate” around jurisdiction has hamstrung it in contrast to the E.U. Rather than trying to fit digital assets into existing frameworks, he praised the MiCA for taking a “bespoke” approach to crafting regulations that provide more clarity for businesses and regulators in the bloc.
“You cannot operate in a box,” Linch told Decrypt. “If you don’t create a good path for good actors to behave well, all you’ve done is cleared the way for bad actors to act nefariously.”
Coinbase Is Speeding Up Plans to Expand Outside the US
Coinbase has been setting its sights on growth outside the U.S., but declined to comment directly on a report from Bloomberg saying it’s already talking to international clients about those plans. Instead, a Coinbase spokesperson told Decrypt in an email that the company is accelerating work on its “Go Broad, Go Deep” strategy, revealed earlier this month, which includes growing its presence on every continent except for Antarctica. “Our international expansion drive will focus on high-bar regul...
Experts interviewed by Decrypt do not think the U.S. is incapable of closing the current gap with Europe.
They point to the fact the U.S. still has a significantly deeper capital markets than anywhere in Europe, and a wider pool of talent that will ensure its competitiveness. Congress is also likely to move forward on a pair of bills that are on their way to the House for a vote on the floor after narrowly making it out of their respective committees in July.
Beyond catching up to the rest of the world, executives also warn that any failure of the U.S. to get its act together will weigh crypto down globally because of its standing as the world’s financial powerhouse.
The US Dollar Is Under Threat, Says Circle CEO in Warning to Congress
Circle CEO Jeremy Allaire had a firm warning for policymakers on Thursday: Protect stablecoins or the US dollar will lose global dominance. “If the dollar is to remain the world reserve currency… then we need to build trust in digital dollars and regulate stablecoins today,” said Allaire in a glossy video ad shared on Twitter. What does a cup of coffee have to do with the future of the global economic system? As the US Congress prepares for its first vote on Stablecoin laws, US political lea...
Dave Weisberger, the CEO of the trading platform CoinRoutes, said that Europe's embrace of ETF-like products are "not as big of a mover" for bringing more financial players into Bitcoin compared to the current crop of U.S. applicants because of the heft Wall Street would bring to the table.
For reference, Jacobi holds about $894 million in assets under management, according to the company’s 13F filing with the SEC. This is a far cry from the nearly $8.6 trillion AUM recorded by BlackRock last year—or the $4.5 trillion recorded by Fidelity.
"It is a very big deal in terms of the ability for Bitcoin to go mainstream, whereas none of the European actions really make that big of a difference," Weisberger told Decrypt.
EU Reaches Agreement on Crypto Asset Regulations in Banking
The European Union (EU) has reached a political agreement on changes to the Capital Requirements Regulation and Directive, including new regulations for crypto assets. This move comes in response to lawmakers' calls for stringent rules to prevent “unbacked cryptocurrencies” from infiltrating the traditional financial system. The announcement of this agreement was made public via a tweet from the European Parliament's Economic and Monetary Affairs committee. The tweet followed a meeting that brou...
Yet it is this same sense of incumbency that could also be holding the U.S. back, warned Ness. A sense that the U.S. market is in an unchallenged position means that the rest of the world will have no option but to wait until regulators sort out their positions.
This, Lowell says, is shortsighted because companies are already moving overseas rather than waiting for the U.S. to get its act together.
"The problem I think the SEC is missing is that individuals and entities are already starting to realize that they can be based in other places and still be connected to the global financial system with very little difference," said Lowell.
