The EthereumEthereum co-founder took a shot at Swan Bitcoin’s marketing associate Nick Payton, who argued Thursday that any cryptocurrency that powers a proof of stakeblockchain—which uses validators with pledged, or “staked,” assets to verify transactions—is a security.
“The fact that you can vote on something to change its properties is proof that it’s a security,” Payton said. The insult hits at a sore spot for a crypto industry that has for years battled with the Securities and Exchange Commission—and one that is particularly touchy for Ethereum investors, since the matter of whether or not ETH should be considered a security remains an open question.
Early Friday morning, Buterin called Payton’s assertion a “bare-faced lie.”
It's amazing how some PoW proponents just keep repeating the unmitigated bare-faced lie that PoS includes voting on protocol parameters (it doesn't, just like PoW doesn't) and this so often just goes unchallenged.
“It's amazing how some [proof-of-work] proponents just keep repeating the unmitigated bare-faced lie that [proof-of-stake] includes voting on protocol parameters (it doesn't, just like [proof-of-work] doesn't) and this so often just goes unchallenged,” he said, adding, “Nodes reject invalid blocks, in [proof-of-stake] and in [proof-of-work]. It's not hard.”
Proof of workProof of work, which involves the participation of “miners” who devote large amounts of computing power to solve complex, mathematical problems, is currently how both Bitcoin and Ethereum validate transactions and secure their networks. Ethereum, however, is in the process of transitioning to proof of stake through a long-awaited update now known as “the Merge.”
In his defense of proof of stake, Buterin took his retort one step further with a tongue-in-cheek “grammar” correction for the editor.
Also, small grammar nuance: in English when talking about things like proof of stake, we don't say "it's a security", we say "it's secure". I know these suffixes are hard though, so I forgive the error.
“In English when talking about things like proof of stake, we don't say “It's a security," we say "it's secure." I know these suffixes are hard though, so I forgive the error,” Buterin said.
While Bankless founder Ryan Sean Adams called the retort “the spiciest Vitalik tweet I’ve ever read,” this is far from the first time Buterin’s gotten into arguments with anti-Ethereum Bitcoiners online.
Earlier this month Buterin responded to Bitcoin maximalist Jimmy Song, who argued that proof of stake “does not provide decentralized consensus” because it does not, in Song’s view, solve The Byzantine Generals Problem. Song was referring to the problem of achieving consensus without some centralization through a trusted single party. ConsensusConsensus in crypto is achieved when multiple entities are all able to agree on the same data without the intervention of a central authority—this enables blockchain transactions.
Pro-tip: if there's a long-established tradition of people debating A vs B based on deep arguments touching on math, economics and moral philosophy, and you come along saying "B is dumb because of a one-line technicality involving definitions", you're probably wrong. https://t.co/22N0OaHyz1
But for Vitalik, Song’s argument hinges on a “technicality.”
“If there's a long-established tradition of people debating A vs B based on deep arguments touching on math, economics and moral philosophy, and you come along saying “B is dumb because of a one-line technicality involving definitions,” you're probably wrong,” Buterin said.
Editor's note: This article was updated to reflect Nick Payton's current title at Swan Bitcoin.
Daily Debrief Newsletter
Start every day with the top news stories right now, plus original features, a podcast, videos and more.
The San Francisco Bitcoin Meetup holiday party in December 2017 was packed with crypto hopefuls.
Bitcoin had just hit nearly $20,000. Ethereum was holding steady above $700. Under the glow of fluorescent lights and an air of optimism, two young men posed for a photo that would become one of crypto’s most enduring snapshots.
Frédéric Fortier wore an Ethereum sweater. Mathieu Baril wore a Bitcoin one. Their image landed in a New York Times feature published weeks later under the headline: Everyone...
The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission has delayed its decision on in-kind redemptions for the Bitwise Bitcoin ETF Trust and Bitwise Ethereum ETF, according to a filing on Wednesday, the latest sign of U.S. regulators' restraint even as the political environment for crypto has improved.
The SEC will rule by September 8, according to the filing, and could at that point approve or deny the request, or elect to review the matter further, the document said.
“The Commission finds it appropriate...
The price of XRP hit a six-month high on Wednesday as notional open interest for the third largest cryptocurrency by market capitalization surged to record levels.
The Ripple-linked coin was recently trading hands around $3.05, a 5.1% increase over the past day, according to crypto data provider CoinGecko. The asset’s price has climbed as high as $3.31 within the past year, while soaring 420% over the same period.
Notional open interest for XRP perpetual futures, which reflects the amount of mon...