A crypto advocacy group that’s targeted industry skeptics on Capitol Hill is sounding off against Prometheum, accusing the much-contested crypto firm of carrying water for the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) with its emergent Ethereum business.
Prometheum launched custody services for Ethereum on Friday, offering to safeguard the asset on customers’ behalf after months of anticipation, per Fortune. The catch: Prometheum's service classifies Ethereum as a security under the SEC’s remit.
The SEC has not yet made this declaration, though the agency has been accused of internally operating on that premise amid its ever-expanding crypto industry crackdown. Last month, Ethereum software giant Consensys filed suit against the SEC on just that point, seeking confirmation from a court that Ethereum is in fact not a security (disclosure: Consensys is one of 22 investors in Decrypt).
“This announcement is simply the latest attempt orchestrated by the SEC to drive the crypto market out of the United States,” the Cedar Innovation Foundation said of the Prometheum offering in a statement. “The SEC and Prometheum stand alone in their claim that ETH is a security.”
SEC Has Secretly Considered Ethereum a Security Since 2023, Says Consensys in Unredacted Lawsuit
The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has internally considered Ethereum to be a security for over a year, according to previously redacted portions of a lawsuit filed by software giant Consensys against the SEC that were revealed this morning. Per Consensys’ complaint, Gurbir Grewal, the Commission’s Director of the Division of Enforcement, issued an internal Formal Order on March 28, 2023, announcing an investigation into “Ethereum 2.0,” authorizing employees of the regulator to in...
While U.S. financial regulators like the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) have asserted that Ethereum is a commodity, Prometheum’s business could disrupt that notion. As the SEC has accused crypto exchanges of flouting securities laws, Prometheum has also sought out novel licenses to offer digital asset trading.
Arguing its business has satisfied regulatory requirements where others have not, Prometheum has drawn widespread ire in an industry that advocates say is maligned with uncertainty. While the firm has reportedly not launched the trading of Ethereum as a security, offering customers custody services is being billed as an prerequisite step.
The Cedar Innovation Foundation claimed Prometheum’s business is part of a “desperate attempt to misclassify ETH as a security,” an alleged scheme that it believes will be stifled through litigation. Calling out SEC Chair Gary Gensler, the organization said, “It’s time for Congress to put an end to Gensler’s political machinations.”
Ethereum Spikes 9% Within Minutes on ETF Approval Rumors
The price of Ethereum spiked by 9% in a matter of minutes Monday afternoon amid speculation from analysts that the United States Securities and Exchange Commission will indeed approve spot Ethereum exchange traded funds (ETFs). Ethereum jumped from a price of $3,143 to $3,428 in a span of approximately 20 minutes, per data from CoinGecko. Its 24-hour jump sits at 11% as of this writing, based on the current price of $3,410. Bloomberg analysts Eric Balchunas and James Seyffart now say they're 75%...
However, the ruckus around Prometheum was largely overshadowed Monday by speculation that the SEC could soon approve spot Ethereum ETFs—a stunning about-face compared to growing skepticism around such prospects in recent weeks. Positing that a change in the SEC's posture was motivated by political pressure, Bloomberg ETF analysts Eric Balchunas and James Seyffart raised their approval odds to 75% from 25%.
The proposed ETFs classify Ethereum as a commodity—not a digital asset security as Prometheum's business does.
Prometheum burst onto the crypto scene last summer after its co-CEO Aaron Kaplan testified before Congress about the SEC’s regulatory approach to crypto. Saying the SEC had clearly laid out a path to compliance for firms, Kaplan’s comments proved controversial as the little-known firm touted its unique membership with the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA).
Ethereum ETF Approval Coming Sooner Rather Than Later, Says Coinbase
A spot Ethereum exchange-traded fund (ETF) could hit the market sooner than expected, says Coinbase, despite growing industry observer pessimism. In a note this week, America’s biggest cryptocurrency exchange said that “while there is uncertainty around a timely approval given the SEC’s apparent silence with issuers,” it’s only a matter of time before such a product hits the market. There’s a long list of top asset managers—including VanEck, BlackRock, and Franklin Templeton—who have filed pape...
Taking years to realize its vision as a so-called market ecosystem for digital asset securities, lawmakers questioned how Prometheum could become a poster boy for SEC compliance without offering any products or services. Since then, Prometheum has worked steadily towards achieving that goal, much to the crypto industry’s chagrin.
Prometheum did not immediately respond to a request for comment from Decrypt.
While the Cedar Innovation Foundation notes on its website that crypto education is core to its mission, the organization has also been linked to spending on political advertisements against lawmakers like Sherrod Brown (D-OH), who has publicly warned against crypto’s risks before.
Edited by Andrew Hayward
