Last week, Lido put forward a governance proposal to limit the amount of Ethereum that users can stake after facing criticism from the crypto community.
"Who will be the first staking provider to publicly commit to limiting themselves to not operating more than 22% of validators on the chain?" tweeted Ethereum's Beacon Chain community manager Superphiz. "Who do you want to see step up to the plate and prioritize beacon chain health above profits?"
Lido is a liquid staking service, that lets users deposit assets like Ethereum, Solana, Polygon, and others to earn a yield. Whenever users stake these assets, they receive another staked version of the same token, which can be used elsewhere in the market.
Lido's staking service has become extremely popular of late, raising concerns about a large amount of Ethereum currently concentrated in one staking pool.
Despite centralization worries, voting for this latest proposal has thus far been extremely one-sided, with nearly 99.8% of the Lido community voting against limiting how much Ethereum Lido can service. Less than 0.2% of holders have voted in favor of the proposal.
The vote is scheduled to end by July 1, 2022.
Lido and Ethereum upgrade
It should also be said that these concerns are coming just two months before Ethereum's Merge event. The ETH staked on Lido is added to the Ethereum Beacon Chain, a proof-of-stake (PoS) version of the original blockchain.
Following the Merge event slated for this August, all of Ethereum will move to the Beacon Chain, launching the long-awaited Ethereum 2.0 upgrade.
More Videos
0 seconds of 38 minutes, 57 secondsVolume 90%
Press shift question mark to access a list of keyboard shortcuts
ConsenSys CEO Joe Lubin talked about Ethereum 2.0 timing and impact, the power of DAOs, and gave his honest take on NFTs, Solana, Polygon, and Biden's crypto executive order in an extensive fireside chat with Decrypt's Dan Roberts at Camp Ethereal 2022 in Wyoming.
After Lido, other large depositors include Kraken (8.53%), Binance (6.77%), Staked.us (3.02%) and Stakefish (2.14%).
For decentralization maximalists, Lido's dominance is a serious concern.
"Speculative controversial take: we should legitimize price gouging by top stake pool providers," tweeted Ethereum's co-creator Vitalik Buterin. "Like, if a stake pool controls [more than] 15%, it should be accepted and even expected for the pool to keep increasing its fee rate until it goes back below 15%."
Unpacking Lido's centralization concerns
Lido's dominant staking position could pose risks to the decentralized model of the network and lead to attacks, according to Danny Ryan, a researcher at Ethereum Foundation.
"Lido passing 1/3 is a centralization attack on PoS," he tweeted. "We're bad at assessing tail risk, but staking in Lido at these thresholds has a lot of it."
Lido passing 1/3 is a centralization attack on PoS.
We're bad at assessing tail risk, but staking in Lido at these thresholds has a lot of it.
In blockchain systems, tail risk isn't even necessarily so far fetch. Systems tend to hit edge cases, systems tend to get exploited 1/2
"Lido was started with two simple aims: to democratize access to staking, and to prevent centralized exchanges from gaining the lion's share of staked Ethereum," tweeted Lido in response to centralized attack possibility claims. "In short, to keep Ethereum decentralized."
The current proof-of-workproof-of-work (PoW) consensus model also has these threats. But the need for high computational resources safeguards the network.
Daily Debrief Newsletter
Start every day with the top news stories right now, plus original features, a podcast, videos and more.
Digital assets may be firmly in the mainstream, with institutional involvement and a crypto-friendly president in the White House.
But hackers and fraudsters are having a field day so far this year.
Crypto users have lost over $1.7 billion to these groups—already 14% more than 2024’s total losses of $1.49 billion, according to blockchain security firm Immunefi.
In the same period last year, losses totaled $420 million, the firm said.
The report comes amid ongoing concerns about the vulnerabil...
Libre, a regulated real-world asset platform, and the TON Foundation have launched a $500 million tokenized fund on The Open Network, aiming to bring Telegram’s $2.4 billion in corporate debt onto the blockchain for the first time.
Dubbed the Telegram Bond Fund, the product allows institutional and accredited investors to gain exposure to Telegram’s outstanding bonds directly through the TON blockchain, according to a statement shared with Decrypt.
The fund will also participate in future Telegr...
Solana decentralized exchange Raydium has deployed its native token launchpad, which is designed to rival the popular Pump.fun. This comes almost a month after Pump.fun deployed its own decentralized exchange, cutting ties with Raydium in the process.
LaunchLab by Raydium offers a more sophisticated token creation process, compared to Pump.fun’s simplistic approach. The new launchpad allows for deployers to toy with the token supply, how many tokens will be sold on the bonding curve, and how muc...
