In brief
- China's Wuhan Kingold Jewelry used at least 83 tonnes of counterfeit gold as collateral for loans.
- The gold was used to secure loans worth in excess of $2 billion.
- The discovery raises questions about the practicality of gold as an asset.
An investigation has uncovered one of the biggest gold counterfeiting scandals in recent history.
The probe, carried out by Chinese news outlet Caixin found that Wuhan Kingold Jewelry, the largest privately-owned gold processor in central China’s Hubei province, used at least 83 tonnes of counterfeit gold as collateral for loans amounting to 20 billion yuan ($2.8 billion) from over a dozen Chinese financial institutions.
According to the report, the faked collateral is equivalent to 22% of China's annual gold production and 4.2% of the state gold reserve as of 2019. In short, more than four percent of China's official gold reserves may be fake.
The counterfeit metal was discovered in February when one of Kingold’s lenders, Dongguan Trust, decided to liquidate its collateral to cover defaulted debts. Following the discovery, three other Kingold creditors also performed tests on the gold in their vaults and found it was fake.
Kingold was founded in 2002 by Jia Zhihong, who reportedly served in the military and once managed gold mines owned by the People’s Liberation Army. Kingold started off as a gold factory affiliated with the People’s Bank of China but split off from the central bank during restructuring. As of September 2019, it held assets totaling $3.3 billion, and its shares are listed on the Nasdaq stock exchange.
How much gold held as collateral is fake?
It’s not the first time fake gold has been used as collateral in China. In 2016, regulators found gold bars with black tungsten at their center, backing 19 billion yuan of loans ($2.5 billion.)
A special government task force has been set up to further investigate the fraud.
But the latest revelations are sure to spark questions about how much gold held as collateral is genuine, and how practical gold is as a reserve asset. In the last four years, at least $50 million worth of fake gold allegedly from Swiss refineries has been found in the vaults of JPMorgan Chase, one of the largest banks at the center of the bullion market.
Bitcoin's price has outperformed gold by 100% this year
Despite its ups and downs this year, Bitcoin (BTC) has put on a strong performance and is now up 32% YTD—outperforming gold by a wide margin. Bitcoin started 2020 strong and climbed from a starting point of just $7,200 up to as high as $10,400 by mid-February, equivalent to a 44% gain in under two months. This bullish momentum was cut short as Bitcoin gradually dropped off in the following month, due to a global market sell-off amidst concerns surrounding the spread of the Coronavirus. Bitcoin t...
Cryptocurrency often gets a bad rap for scams, but it’s relatively straightforward to discover if it’s fake; software can scan the Bitcoin blockchain to prove its veracity—a process that costs almost nothing.
